Salina, KS  | Official Website Logo Salina, KS  | Official Website Sticky Logo
  • Residents
    Community Resources
    Animal Services Building and Construction Elections Housing and Neighborhoods Pay A Ticket or Fine Recreation Trash Service Water Service Park Finder
    Living in Salina
    Arts and Culture Volunteer Opportunities Schools Smoky Hill Museum
    Public Safety
    Police Fire Report Problems Saline County Sheriff
    Transportation
    Salina CityGo Bus System Salina Airport KanCycle Bike Sharing
  • Business
    Build Your Business
    Start a Business in Salina Register Your Business in Kansas Salina Community Economic Development Organization Salina Area Chamber of Commerce Salina Downtown Inc
    Business Resources
    Make a Payment Report a Problem Trash Service Water Service
    Working with the City
    Bids and Purchasing Building and Construction Engineering Planning and Zoning
  • Government
    Boards and Commissions
    City Commission Sign Up for Email Notifications Volunteer for a Board or Commission Current City Commission Agendas and Minutes Other Boards and Commissions Agendas and Minutes Channel 20 Schedule Prior City Commission Packets
    Departments
    Arts and Humanities City Clerk's Office City Manager's Office Computer Technology Department Community and Development Services Finance and Administration Department Fire Department
    Departments
    Human Resources Department Municipal Court Parks and Recreation Department Police Department Public Works Department Utilities Department Water Department
    Records
    Public Records Request Municipal Code
  • I Want To
    Apply
    Boards and Commissions Jobs Permits Licenses
    Bids and Purchasing
    Requests Tabulations
    Learn More
    Public Notices and Legal Publications Document Archive Municipal Code City Maps City Budget Gypsum Hill Cemetery Fiber Optic Cable Installation FAQ Public Notifications 2025 Comprehensive Fee Schedule
    Submit a Complaint
    Junk and Trash Dangerous Structures Grass and Weeds Roads Other City Fair Housing Equal Opportunity Employment Public Accommodation and ADA Police Department
    Submit Payment
    Water Bill Taxes Abatements Special Assessments
    Submit a Request
    Inspection Start or Stop Trash Service Special Trash Pickup Start or Stop Water Service Submit a Public Records Request Submit a Service Request Community Proclamation
    Reserve
    Park Shelters Neighborhood Centers and Lodges Downtown Plaza Downtown Parking Lot Food Truck Parking Spot Field House Space and Time Athletic Spaces and Fields
  • Jobs
    Apply
    Job Openings
    Join Salina PD
    Join Salina Fire Department
    Human Resources
    Why Choose Salina?
  • Payments
    Make a Payment
View All

Statement Regarding the Cozy Inn vs. City of Salina Case

Salina, KS  | Official Website News Image

6/3/2025 10:39:00 AM

STATEMENT REGARDING THE COZY INN, ET AL. V. CITY OF SALINA[1] Case No. 6:24-cv-01027-TC


On February 19, 2024, the Cozy Inn sued the City of Salina.  The lawsuit was filed by Plaintiffs’ attorneys, the Kansas Justice Institute, which according to their website is “a free public interest litigation firm” located in Overland Park, Kansas.  In an article published by Salina311, written by the Kansas Justice Institute (“KJI”), KJI declared this case “is part of KJI’s litigation campaign challenging laws that interfere with the right to free speech.  It’s also part of KJI’s litigation efforts to fight back against city hall.”  


The lawsuit claimed the Salina Sign Code is content-based and unconstitutional, is unconstitutionally vague and a prior restraint.   


Like most other local governments, the City of Salina regulates signs to avoid sign clutter and to promote traffic safety and community aesthetics City-wide.  In a recent case entitled, City of Austin v. Reagan Nat’l Advert., the United States Supreme Court described sign regulation as a tradition dating back more than 150 years and recognized that tens of thousands of jurisdictions regulate signs.  The City has regulated signs for more than 50 years. The City’s ordinance defines the term “sign” to include displays that “announce, direct attention to, or advertise” and are “not located inside a building” as “building” is defined in Salina Code Sec. 42-637.  At least 34 other municipalities across the United States utilize the phrase “announce, direct attention to, or advertise” in their definitions of signs.


The City believes its definition of sign is content neutral, constitutional, and the City contends it has been consistent in applying its Sign Code in a content neutral matter.  


The pleadings and motions filed in this matter provide a more complete factual background.  All documents filed in this matter may be accessed on the PACER website at https://pacer.uscourts.gov/.


This statement will include some of the factual background addressed in the filed pleadings and motions.[2]  Applying the definition of sign from the Sign Code, the City determined the painting on the side wall of The Cozy Inn was a sign.  Plaintiffs did not obtain a sign permit before they began painting the sign.   The Cozy Inn sign exceeds The Cozy Inn’s allowable sign area.  The City informed Mr. Howard that the Cozy Sign was too big to qualify for a permit. During an in-person meeting on November 13, 2023, the City provided Mr. Howard with a memorandum explaining why the Cozy Sign was too large to qualify for a sign permit.  The City offered to work with Mr. Howard to see if a code-based solution could be reached.   In doing so, the City engaged a sign consultant that would help the City evaluate if the Salina community was in favor of permitting wall signs as large as the Cozy Inn on the sides of smaller buildings, and if the City could amend the Sign Code in a content-neutral fashion while continuing to advance its content-neutral purposes, including but not limited to avoiding sign clutter, promoting traffic safety and community aesthetics City-wide.  Unbeknownst to the City, Mr. Howard was in contact with the Kansas Justice Institute on November 11, 2023, to ask about representation in this case. 


The filing of the lawsuit ensued, which set in motion discovery obligations, and pleading and motion deadlines.  The City defended the action and complied with the requirements of civil litigation in Federal Court.  Throughout the litigation, the City has steadfastly held the position that Salina’s Sign Code is constitutional.


The City and Plaintiffs have filed summary judgment motions in this case.  The Court has advised that a ruling on the motions is anticipated on or about August 8, 2025.  The Court further advised that if one or more claims survive, a bench trial beginning October 7, 2025 will occur.


[1] The City is aware of certain media reports and social media commentary that were not initiated by the City or its counsel regarding the federal case of Cozy Inn, Incorporated d/b/a The Cozy Inn; Stephen Howard v. City of Salina, Kansas, Civil Action No. 6:24-cv-01027-TC-ADM, which is currently pending in the United States District Court, District of Kansas. Some of the reports and commentary have inaccurately described the facts, circumstances, and stakes of the case.  As such, the City is releasing this statement.  The statements contained herein are statements that have been set forth in public record, such as pleadings or motions filed in The Cozy Inn, et al. v. City of Salina case, United States Supreme Court decisions, news articles or websites.  Accordingly, this statement shall not be construed as a waiver of any applicable privilege.  Outside of the information contained in this statement, at this time the City will not provide further public comment.  


[2] The City’s Brief in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment with exhibits, the City’s Reply Brief in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment with exhibits, the City’s Brief in Support of its Motion to Dismiss, the City’s Reply Brief in Support of its Motion to Dismiss, as well as the Court’s Amended Pre-Trial Order may be accessed here: Cozy Inn Legal Documents

Image
Category News
False
Author No content items.

Residents

Animal Services Arts & Culture Building & Construction Employment Living in Salina Housing & Neighborhoods Public Safety Recreation Report Problems Transportation

Business

Boards & Commission Fireworks Volunteer Opportunities E-waste Event Surplus Property Saline County Flood

Government

Comprehensive Fee Schedule Applications, Certificates, Licenses & Permits Open Public records Submit a Service Request Bids & Purchasing Building & Construction

Services

Municipal Code Economic Development Engineering Planning & Zoning Public Safety Transportation Working in Salina Utilities Voter Registration Email Notifications
City Of Salina
Connect With Us
Sitemap Site Terms Privacy Policy Government Websites by GovBuilt, an MCCi brand My Profile
City Of Salina
Connect With Us
Sitemap Site Terms Privacy Policy Website by GovBuilt My Profile